Some Keywords Still Earn Clicks Even When AI Overviews Appear
You might look at AI Overviews in search results and think, well, there go my clicks. I get it. Many people are seeing big drops, sometimes in places you would not expect. But despite the sharp decline for some pages, not every keyword dries up when an AI Overview shows up. A few keep their click-through steady, or even benefit.
I wondered if there is a pattern behind these outlier keywords. The ones that still push people to visit your site, even with AI answers right there on Google. So I dug into data, ran some tests, looked at client sites, and found a few trends that might help you create a smarter SEO strategy.
Here is what I noticed.
AI Overviews Usually Lower Clicks
Let’s not sugarcoat this. Traffic often goes down when AI Overviews appear. Several studies have found a drop of about 30 to 40 percent for affected keywords. My own data lines up with this.
Why does this happen? When Google shows a well-written, AI-generated summary right on the page, many people don’t see any need to click through. That’s it. It is efficient in a way that does not really benefit you as a publisher.
If people get the information right away, most will save the extra click. They just want a quick answer.
But there is more to it. Google does not always nail the result. And not every query fits neatly into an AI Overview. This leaves the door open for clicks when users want something a bit more, or different, than what Google’s AI offers.
What Sets “AI-Resistant” Keywords Apart?
When I skim client search data, a few types of queries stand out. These keep drawing clicks even with an AI summary at the top. Three common threads surface, and each has real world examples (I avoided using my competitor’s, so you get something fresh).
1. People Searching for Free Tools or Utilities
AI can summarize facts, but it can’t run a calculator for you, or generate a password. When someone types in “free invoice template” or “password generator,” they are not there for a short paragraph, they need to interact with a tool.
For example, I’ve seen steady traffic to:
– A caloric needs calculator
– Free privacy policy generators
– Time-zone converters
People click because they have a job to do. AI Overviews may describe what a tool does, but they don’t offer the tool itself.
Users will skip summaries and click when they need to use a live tool or download a file.
If you publish tools, check your top queries. These pages often hold their click-through rates, even as AI becomes more present.
2. Queries That Recently Improved in Rank
When pages go from the deeper part of page two to page one, sometimes even just into an AI Overview, they tend to see higher click-through. Yes, even with AI present.
Here is the thing: these pages were not getting many clicks before. There was nowhere to fall. So a move up is still a win, even if AI eats into some of the potential. This is especially true for niche software pages, recent comparison posts, or timely product guides.
For example:
– A page moving from position 13 to 7
– A career guide that broke into the top 10 after an update
It is proof that on-page SEO, updating old content, and building links can still matter, even as AI grows. It’s not always the doomsday scenario people fear.
Moving up the results, even with AI in the mix, still beats being buried on page two.
3. Keywords Where AI Overviews Are Not in the First Position
AI Overviews do not always claim the top spot. I checked a batch of client keywords and noticed that sometimes, the AI summary is in the second, third, or even fourth position in the results.
And when that happens, the page in first place often keeps most of its clicks. Placement matters more than I expected. It’s not just that AI is present, but where Google decides to put it.
For instance:
– “Course reviews for ProjectX” might have a featured snippet, then AI Overview, then site links.
– “Best day trip in Vermont” could have a local map pack, then a couple organic links, then AI Overview.
If you still claim the top human-written result, you usually hold strong.
Testing Keywords for AI Impact: Try This Yourself
So, how do you run this test with your own data? Here is the actual process, step by step. (No fancy words. Just what works.)
Start in Google Search Console
– Go to your “Performance” report.
– Set a filter for the region that matters to your business.
– Filter for queries with 100 or more impressions (you need some volume for this to mean much).
– Sort or filter by click-through rate, watching for keywords that stayed flat or increased in the past three months.
– Export that list.
Spot AI Overviews in Live Search
– Search some of those keywords yourself, in incognito.
– Jot down where, if anywhere, AI Overviews appear in the results.
– Mark those where you still get traffic, despite the presence of an AI summary.
You can also use tools that track SERP features, but nothing beats seeing it with your own eyes, at least for a sample.
What Does This Mean for Your SEO Plan?
If organic traffic from informational queries is a big part of your strategy, you can’t ignore AI Overviews. But there are ways to adapt that do not mean starting over.
Focus your time on pages that:
– Offer interactive value (not just info)
– Rank newly on the first page
– Stay in top spots even when an AI Overview is lower down
It might be worth adding a “free tool” section if your content allows. Or update older posts now stuck on page two. And keep an eye on where AI summaries show up for your best keywords.
Should you chase after only the AI-resistant keywords? No, that’s too limiting, and things change all the time. But you can shift your balance, experiment, and measure the impact.
Some niches, like recipes or breaking news, will always be tough. If Google can fully answer the question, expect fewer clicks. But in software, education, local services, and “how-to” spaces, you still have room to play.
Do Keywords Ever Recover After AI Summaries?
This is complicated. Sometimes when AI gets it wrong or provides thin information, user behavior shifts back and more people click through eventually. You see this most in medical research, legal questions, and anything where nuance matters.
Here’s the catch: Google frequently changes which queries trigger an AI Overview. So, today’s drop may turn around in a few months without you making any adjustments. It happens.
Why Do Free Tools Still Get Clicks?
People want results, not just explanations. Summaries cannot generate a budget spreadsheet for you, or spit out a business name suggestion. The intent is action, not just learning.
You can test this yourself: if you search “BMI calculator,” Google often gives you a mini-calculator, but many users skip it and click on a full-featured tool anyway. They want something printable or more detailed.
Table: Example Search Intent Types and Likelihood of AI CTR Impact
| Intent Type | Example Query | AI Impact | Likely User Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Question | “Who invented the lightbulb?” | High | No click needed |
| Step-by-step Tutorial | “How to tie a tie” | Medium | Some click for detail |
| Interactive Tool | “Mortgage calculator” | Low | User clicks |
| Download Resource | “Resume template PDF” | Low | User clicks |
| Complex Comparison | “Project management software ratings” | Medium | User often clicks for nuance |
Create Content With Clear Value Gaps
When building new pages, always look for value gaps between what an AI summary can offer and what people actually want.
Ask yourself:
– Is my content interactive?
– Does it offer something a summary cannot, like community comments, fresh data, or tools?
– Do I give real instructions or just repeat facts?
If you can check “yes” on the above, you are more resistant.
What About Google Updating How AI Overviews Work?
Google keeps tuning how and where they show AI Overviews. Sometimes an AI snapshot replaces the featured snippet, sometimes it pushes it down. Every now and then, Google will change an algorithm and a batch of keywords will suddenly be AI-summary free.
It is frustrating, but also creates windows of opportunity if you catch the shifts soon enough.
Final Q&A
Can you predict which keywords will become “AI proof” forever?
Not really. Trends change, Google experiments, industries evolve. But if you watch your GSC data, focus on high-intent and tool-based queries, and stay flexible, you will always be closer to the answer than those who rely on luck.
Should I stop optimizing for keywords with AI Overviews?
No, not entirely. Sometimes Google will stop showing the overview, or tweak the algorithm in your favor. Plus, even low click-through can mean solid conversions if you tailor your offers.
Are click numbers for these keywords consistent across countries?
No. What works in the US may not work in Germany or Japan. Search intent and AI rollout can be very different by location. Always check your own data for your key markets.
What should I do next?
Review the keywords where you have stayed strong or improved, even in the presence of AI summaries. See what they have in common. Try to model more content after your winners, and pay less attention to those you cannot seem to push.
If you are curious, which types of queries are giving your pages steady traffic? And which dropped sharply after AI was introduced? Everyone sees something a little different, and sometimes the most valuable insights come from your own pattern spotting.
Need a quick summary of this article? Choose your favorite AI tool below:
